FootballPakistan's IMF Review: Revenue Shortfalls, Delayed Reforms and an Uncertain Path for External Financing

Pakistan's IMF Review: Revenue Shortfalls, Delayed Reforms and an Uncertain Path for External Financing

**মূল উত্তর**: পাকিস্তানের চলমান আইএমএফ কর্মসূচি পর্যালোচনা ৭ বিলিয়ন ডলারের ইএফএফ ও ১.৪ বিলিয়ন ডলারের আরএসএফ সুবিধার Next কিস্তি ছাড়ের শর্ত যাচাই করছে। মূল চ্যালেঞ্জ হলো রাজস্ব আদায়ের লক্ষ্যমাত্রা অর্জন, বিলম্বিত আইন সংস্কার এবং বাহ্যিক ঋণ পুনঃঅর্থায়নের অনিশ্চয়তা। **মূল তথ্য**: - ৭ বিলিয়ন ডলারের ইএফএফ ও ১.৪ বিলিয়ন ডলারের আরএসএফ সুবিধা চালু রয়েছে। - চলতি অর্থবছরের প্রথম প্রান্তিকে রাজস্ব আদায়ের লক্ষ্যমাত্রা ৩.০৫৩ ট্রিলিয়ন রুপি। - ১৭৪টি আইন সংশোধনের প্রয়োজন চিহ্নিত, তবে কার্যকর হয়েছে মাত্র ২টি। - দেশে দারিদ্র্যের হার ৪৪.২ শতাংশ। - বার্ষিক প্রায় ১১ বিলিয়ন ডলারের ঋণ পুনঃঅর্থায়ন প্রয়োজন। **উৎস**: স্টেজ-২ গভীর পেশাদার বিশ্লেষণ প্রতিবেদন (মূল প্রকাশের তারিখ নির্দিষ্ট করা হয়নি)। **সম্পর্কিত প্রশ্নোত্তর**: প্রশ্ন: পাকিস্তানের আইএমএফ কর্মসূচির প্রধান শর্তগুলো কী? উত্তর: রাজস্ব আদায়ের লক্ষ্যমাত্রা, ভর্তুকি সংস্কার, আইনগত পরিবর্তন এবং ক্রয়-প্রক্রিয়ার স্বচ্ছতা। প্রশ্ন: পাকিস্তানে দারিদ্র্যের হার কত? উত্তর: ৪৪.২ শতাংশ। প্রশ্ন: পাকিস্তানকে প্রতি বছর কত ঋণ পুনঃঅর্থায়ন করতে হয়? উত্তর: প্রায় ১১ বিলিয়ন ডলার।

Pakistan's ongoing International Monetary Fund (IMF) programme review is not merely an administrative step towards releasing a tranche. It is a combined assessment of a state's revenue structure, expenditure control, procurement transparency, social protection and the sustainability of external financing. At the centre of the review are two main lending facilities — a $7 billion Extended Fund Facility (EFF) and a $1.4 billion Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF). Release of the next tranche depends on meeting the revenue collection target, subsidy reform, completing legislative changes and ensuring procurement transparency. The significance of this review is not only economic but political. Every tranche release is tied to the pace of domestic reform, parliamentary committee scrutiny and the burden of taxation and inflation on the public. Pakistan's negotiations with the IMF are therefore not simply a technical financing arrangement; they are a rewriting of a social contract — the question is who bears the cost of stabilisation. Context: Programme structure and review cycle Pakistan has struggled for years with fiscal deficits, trade deficits and external debt pressure. The tax base is narrow, tax-evasion tendencies are high, and a large share of government spending goes to interest payments. Against this backdrop, an IMF programme provides short-term dollar liquidity and investor confidence, but over the long term becomes a burden of strict conditions. The $7 billion EFF is aimed mainly at medium-term structural reform, while the $1.4 billion RSF supports climate resilience and longer-term structural reform. Both facilities are tied to phased reviews, where each review depends on meeting specific measurable conditions. This review cycle is the programme's core structure — an ongoing monitoring system in which progress is verified and the next tranche released at each stage. The IMF's regular bilateral surveillance, known as Article IV consultations, is closely linked to this framework. It assesses a country's overall economic position, risks and policy progress. In Pakistan's case, surveillance and programme review are running in parallel, underlining the gravity of the situation. Revenue collection: the most sensitive indicator Revenue collection is the most sensitive indicator of this programme. The first-quarter revenue collection target for the current fiscal year has been set at 3.053 trillion rupees. Whether this target is met will largely determine the question of the next tranche. The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) holds primary responsibility for meeting the target. But a narrow tax base, a large informal economy and tax evasion make the target difficult to achieve. The FBR's real challenge is not just collection but broadening the tax base. If no new taxpayers are added and more is extracted from existing ones, the tax burden loses its overall fairness. That is why tax reform is not only a revenue question but a question of social justice. It is worth remembering that broadening the tax base is a slow process. It requires tax administration capacity, digitalisation, use of information technology and political support. Setting a target alone does not increase collection; the target needs an implementation framework behind it. Legislative reform: 174 versus 2 Another key condition of the IMF programme is legislative reform. A total of 174 legislative amendments have been identified as necessary under the programme, but only 2 have been enacted so far. This gap is the programme's biggest practical obstacle. The distance between setting conditions and implementing them is not only a matter of political will but also of administrative slowness. Parliamentary process, political consensus and limited political capital all explain the gap. Where the IMF wants rapid implementation, an elected government has limited time and political room. This reality raises an important question — is there a structural conflict between the timetable of an international lender and the pace of a sovereign state's democratic process? If reform passes through public participation and parliamentary approval, it will naturally be slow. But the IMF review cycle runs on fixed deadlines. This mismatch of pace is the root cause of delay. Parliamentary scrutiny and subsidy reform The National Assembly Standing Committee is playing an active role in scrutinising the reform process. The committee is asking whether the conditions are realistic, what impact they have on the public, and on whom the burden of expenditure control is being placed. This scrutiny is a process of democratic accountability that influences the programme's pace and direction. Subsidy reform is another contentious area. Cutting energy and food subsidies eases the revenue burden, but increases inflationary pressure on low-income groups. Subsidy cuts are therefore not merely a revenue measure; they are a distributional decision that determines which parts of society carry how much of the load. Subsidy reform and tighter revenue collection are directly linked to inflation. When indirect taxes are raised or subsidies cut, the effect spreads through the prices of goods and services. Low- and middle-income households bear most of this inflationary pressure. In other words, those meant to be protected often bear the cost of adjustment — a counter-intuitive outcome that is a major challenge to the programme's social acceptability. Poverty and social protection In this context, the most worrying fact is the poverty rate. The country's poverty rate has reached 44.2 percent, meaning nearly half the population lives below or near the poverty line. Against this backdrop, applying fiscal austerity and subsidy cuts together risks increasing social pressure. In social protection, the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) plays a leading role. Through this programme, low-income families receive cash assistance. But the key question is how effective this assistance is relative to the inflation caused by subsidy cuts. If cash support is not adjusted for inflation, its real purchasing power declines. Experts often say that the stronger the social protection framework, the lower the political and social risk of subsidy reform. In other words, cash assistance is not only a welfare measure but a precondition for reform. If protection is weak, reform loses public support and implementation fails. Procurement and transparency On transparency and good governance, procurement reform is important. Through Pakistan's Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) and the Electronic Public Acquisition and Disposal System (EPADS), the aim is to make government procurement more transparent and accountable. An electronic platform can reduce corruption and favouritism, which is consistent with the IMF's conditions. Another reform is mandatory asset declarations. Transparent declaration of officials' assets helps prevent corruption. But for such a requirement to work, strong oversight, verification and penalties are needed. Filing an asset declaration does not by itself ensure transparency; without verification it becomes a mere formality. The Election Commission of Pakistan also has an important role in this reform process, especially regarding election spending and the transparency of political finance, because opaque political finance is a major source of corruption. Without transparent political finance, anti-corruption reform remains incomplete. External financing: the $11 billion question On external financing, the most important fact is that Pakistan must refinance or roll over about $11 billion of debt each year, and this roll-over depends substantially on participation in the IMF programme. In other words, the relationship with the IMF is not just about tranches; it is the foundation of the entire external financing structure. Bilateral financing from China and Saudi Arabia plays an important role in this structure. Debt roll-overs and deposit support from these two countries help Pakistan maintain external balance. But such bilateral support is conditional and politically sensitive, and its sustainability is closely tied to progress in the IMF programme. Here a strategic dimension of the programme becomes clear. An IMF programme is not merely a loan agreement; it is a signal that sends a message of confidence to other lenders and investors. If the programme is disrupted, that signal weakens and the cost of external financing rises. That is why each review matters not only financially but strategically. The waiver and deferral debate The most contentious question of the programme is whether waivers or deferrals will be granted if conditions are not met. When some conditions are hard to fulfil, the IMF sometimes grants deferrals, but usually in exchange for additional commitments. Each waiver can therefore add to future burdens, and the conditions of the next review can become even harder. To understand this exchange, one must see that getting a waiver does not mean conditions are relaxed but that time is granted. And time is granted in exchange for tougher commitments in the future. Short-term relief can thus create long-term pressure. This dynamic is one of the programme's biggest risks. A contrarian view: reform speed versus expenditure pressure Here an important contradiction emerges. The conventional view is that meeting strict conditions will make the programme succeed and restore economic stability. But the reality is that if the pace of meeting conditions is slower than the pace of spending cuts, only the burden of taxation and inflation rises, while the benefits of reform are delayed. That only 2 of 174 amendments have been completed shows the problem is not only one of will but of capacity. Without parliamentary process, administrative capacity and political consensus, reform stays on paper. The IMF's review framework gives less weight to this capacity dimension, whereas in practice it is decisive. So the real question is not only whether the conditions have been met but how sustainable the reform has been. If a reform runs only on external pressure and lacks domestic ownership, it will not survive after the review ends. That is why the speed and depth of reform must be considered together. The road ahead In the days ahead, three indicators will determine how smooth the next review is — revenue target figures, progress on delayed legislative amendments, and the state of external financing agreements. What these three indicators show together will be the true picture of the programme's progress. The real question is whether Pakistan's reform framework will run only on external pressure or become sustainable on the basis of domestic ownership. The answer will determine how far the programme's social acceptability holds amid 44.2 percent poverty. Because in the final analysis, the success of an economic programme is measured not only in statistics but in its impact on people's lives.

Pakistan's IMF Review: Revenue Shortfalls, Delayed Reforms and an Uncertain Path for External Financing

Related Players